Sniffing Out Which Plant-Based Burgers Smell the Most Like Real Beef
For many meat-eaters, summer barbecues wouldn’t be the same without the mouthwatering aroma of burgers cooking on the grill. But many people are now open to trying plant-based alternatives, as long as they closely resemble real beef’s taste, odour, appearance, and texture. Now, researchers report that the aromas of a couple of plant-based burgers come close to the real deal when they are cooking, though other products still have a long way to go.
The researchers presented their results at the fall meeting of the American Chemical Society (ACS). ACS Fall 2021 is a hybrid meeting held virtually and in person on 22nd–26th August, and on-demand content will be available from 30th August – 30th September. The meeting features more than 7,000 presentations on a wide range of science topics.
‘During the last several years, increasing awareness of the impact of meat production on climate change, as well as meat shortages during the pandemic, have made people more accepting of plant-based alternatives,’ says LiLi Zyzak, PhD, the project’s principal investigator. ‘There are a lot of products out there, and food companies are doing interesting research, but nobody ever publishes anything because it’s a trade secret.’
Although plant-based meat products have been available for more than 20 years, early versions differed from traditional meat. In recent years, many food companies have done extensive research on making proteins from plants such as soy and pea taste more like beef. Newer companies, such as Impossible Foods and Beyond Meat, are competing with industry giants, such as Kellogg’s, Tyson Foods and Nestlé in this market.
Raw hamburger has very little odour, but cooking releases hundreds of volatile compounds that contribute to taste and aroma. ‘The problem with plant-based burgers is that the plant protein itself contributes a strong odour,’ says Zyzak, who is at Eastern Kentucky University. ‘For example, pea protein smells like green, cut grass, so companies have to find a way to mask that aroma. Some use heavy seasonings.’ Another challenge is determining the correct blend of vegetable oils to mimic the fatty meat smell.
Although Zyzak admits she is a through-and-through meat and potatoes person, she was curious how plant-based burgers stack up. ‘We wanted to give consumers an idea of what’s out there so that they can make informed decisions at the grocery store,’ she says.
The researchers analysed the aroma compounds produced by cooking real hamburgers and eight popular brands of plant-based burgers. First, they cooked the burgers and evaluated the aromas using five descriptors: meaty, fatty, buttery, sweet and roasted. Then, they used gas chromatography-mass spectrometry (GC/MS) combined with olfactometry to correlate the aromas with specific odour compounds. To do this, the team injected volatiles from the cooking burgers into the GC/MS instrument, which separated the compounds.
Some of the samples were diverted to a sniffing port, where a person clicked a button when they smelled an individual odour. Using a microphone, the person said which of the five descriptors it smelled like (buttery). MS analysed the remaining sample, and the researchers correlated specific compounds with the aroma smelled by the person at a certain time.
The team then identified the compounds that caused the plant-based burgers to differ from traditional hamburgers. Of the alternatives tested so far, the Beyond Burger from Beyond Meat most closely resembled the odour profile of actual hamburger, with meaty, fatty and grilled meat characteristics from the compounds 1-octen-3-ol, octanal and nonanal; however, it was still significantly different from the real thing.
Another brand had the closest appearance to real raw hamburger, but upon cooking, it had a yeast- or bread-like odour, with higher levels of methyl butanals and propionic acid. A number of the other brands had heavy seasonings that released strong garlicky or barbecue-sauce-like aromas.
Ultimately, Zyzak would like to use her learned to produce a mixture of odour compounds that closely mimic hamburger aroma. She’s also working with a startup company to obtain samples of cell-based meat (lab-grown meat produced by animal cells in fermentation tanks), which she plans to compare with plant-based and regular burgers.